The Variability of SAT® and ACT® Scores

Learn why SAT and ACT scores can stall or drop—and how consistent prep, practice, and retesting help students improve over time.

The Variability of SAT and ACT Scores

Occasionally, a student’s SAT or ACT scores will stay the same or, in rarer cases, decrease from one test to the next.  Why?  And how can we avoid flat or lower scores?

In some cases, low-quality prep is to blame for a lack of score increase.  For our students, however, who have an average score increase of 210 points on the SAT and 6 points on the ACT and literally the most well-trained tutors, that possibility is impossible.  Here are the other reasons a lack of increase or a decrease can occur:

A bad day

Cyclist on the ground after a fall, with a person standing nearby.

We all know that sometimes athletes have good and bad days.  Even performance in very straightforward sports, with no influence from direct competition, varies from one day to the next.  For example, one could presume that runners would have the same time every race (except for gradual improvement over time) when controlling for racing conditions.  Yet even the top runners vary roughly 2% in performance from one race to the next (on the ACT, a 2% variance would equate to almost a full composite point difference on each test).  Male, younger, and slower runners vary the most in performance from one race to the next.¹

We also know from our personal experience that some days we are just mentally quicker than others.  The same is true for students on standardized tests.  Some days they will do better than others (and some will be really good days when a student performs better than usual).

A bad test

Cyclist riding through heavy rain on a city street, cars parked and flags on buildings.

By “bad” test, I simply mean a test that does not fit a student’s knowledge base as well.  Unlike in running, in which all tracks are the same, on the SAT and ACT, there is also variance in content from one test to the next (if there weren’t, each test would be so predictable that students could prep so easily for them that everyone would get a perfect score).  To avoid complete predictability, there are 140 different topics tested just on the Math section of the ACT.  Some topics, such as exponents and percentages, are tested on every exam; however, after students have learned the frequently tested topics, they will be forced to learn increasingly infrequent (and difficult) topics to raise their scores.  Thus, they will have to learn topics tested on only 1 in 2 tests, then those tested on 1 in 4 tests, then those on 1 in 10 tests, etc.  Because of this variance in content from one test to the next, some tests may suit a student significantly better or worse than others, leading to unexpectedly large increases or a lack thereof.

Imperfect Equating

Electrocardiogram (ECG) tracing showing heart rhythm and peaks.

Every SAT and ACT is “equated” to ensure that a hard test has a more generous curve and vice versa (so that students’ scores do not fluctuate simply because they got lucky or unlucky with the difficulty of the test they took). However, the equating process is not perfect. Kristen Mattern, Senior Director in Research at ACT, states in an interview with Tests and the Rest, “The tests are very reliable, but they’re not perfectly reliable. That means that there’s some measurement error, so every time you take a section, your score may be a little higher than your true ability level or may be a little lower.” For example, historically, the September ACT has had one of the most generous curves of the year, closely followed by the October test. However, this year (2019), the October test was delayed and went through an extra equating process; it ended up having an abysmal curve (literally almost every one of my personal students went down in score from September to October — but saw a jump on the December and kept increasing thereafter). Even as the test makers admit that the tests are very reliable, but not perfectly reliable. Students can get lucky or unlucky with a better or worse curve, so their score could go down through no fault of their own.

Taking Breaks

As we wrote about here, the detriment of taking breaks is surprisingly large.  Students who do not take breaks achieve 50% higher score increases (6 points vs. 4 points on the ACT) than those who do.  Thus, breaks in between tests can cause students to yo-yo: they improve but then regress back to where they were originally, improve and then regress, etc, which makes it look like they were not improving.

The solution

Piano keys being played with hands, close-up.

Most problems in life have the same solution: hard work.  The SAT and ACT are no exception.  The more students practice, the less variance there is in their scores.  In foot races, the experienced runners have more predictable times.  The same holds true on the SAT and ACT: the more experienced test takers are less likely to panic and more likely, through practice, to execute consistently.  And, the more topics a student learns, the less variance in scores because they know more and more of even the infrequently tested topics. Finally, students should plan to take the tests multiple times; in the event they have a bad day, a test that does not fit their content knowledge, or get unlucky with an unfavorable curve, they will want to have multiple opportunities to instead have a good day, with a test that fits them well, and a generous curve.

The same spread shows up between the PSAT and the SAT: see the PSAT-to-SAT growth ranges from the College Board’s own data.

The key to success in life is hard work.  The same is true on standardized tests.  With practice and quality prep, even if a student has an unlucky test, they will succeed in the long run — as hard workers always do.

Addendum (updated in 2026):

It is likely that air pollution impacts students’ SAT and ACT scores. The data are compelling, specifically suggesting that particulate matter concentration on a given day can significantly affect cognitive ability and test performance. That probably sounds too crazy to be true, but there is enough evidence of its effect for the Freakonomics Podcast to have recently devoted an entire episode to it (and to update the episode in 2026). If the data is to be believed, air pollution affected percentile performance by an average of half a standard deviation. Applied to the SAT and ACT, pollution levels could cause a student to score about 50 points lower on the SAT and about 1 point lower on the ACT. It’s likely that these changes in score, while caused by pollution levels, are interpreted by the test taker as “having a bad day.” But what caused that “bad day”? Perhaps it truly was just high particulate matter in the air that day.

Summit Prep tutoring center: dartboard with red and blue segments and scattered pencils.
SAT® and ACT® are registered trademarks belonging, respectively, to Collegeboard and ACT, Inc. Neither Collegeboard nor ACT, Inc. is involved with or affiliated with Summit Prep®, nor does the SAT or ACT, Inc. endorse or sponsor any of the products or services offered by Summit Prep®.