Changes to College Admissions

Test-optional is fading. Essays are out. AP scores are in. Here's what's driving the biggest shift in college admissions since Covid.

Changes to College Admissions

Tulane’s recent changes to its admissions policies and guidance reflect the challenges facing college admissions. After looking at Tulane’s changes, we’ll zoom out to the broader implications so students and parents know what to expect in the coming college admission cycles.

Tulane’s Bellwether Changes

Last week, Tulane made three surprising changes:

  • It would like students to submit SAT and ACT scores above a 1300 on the SAT or a 28 on the ACT, and test scores will be required for applicants to its Pathways to Medicine program.
  • It is discontinuing its supplemental essay because AI has made it more or less useless.
  • Submitting AP exam scores above a 4 or a 5 will help a student’s admissions chances, and these scores will be the primary criterion by which applicants will be judged for academic merit scholarships.

This news is very surprising to those who watch college admissions because Tulane has been gaming its college admissions more than most schools, such as by admitting a large majority of its students via Early Decision in order to boost its yield rate (its admit rate for Early Decision was 59% versus 11% for all other applicants). And, in 2022, Inside Higher Ed reported that Tulane admitted 2,249 students through early action and only 106 through regular decision. “Regular decision” applicants were far from regular: Tulane admitted 21 students through early action for every one it admitted through regular decision. In short, the school was on a quest to achieve perceived prestige. And it worked. Tulane rose markedly in the US News and World Report Ranking, and its applicant numbers skyrocketed.

Changes to SAT® and ACT® Score Submission Guidance

Its recent statements mark a definitive shift away from merely boosting its perceived prestige and toward pursuing genuine academic excellence. Last year, only 38% of Tulane’s freshman class submitted test scores, and the middle 50th percentile of scores of those who did submit test scores was a 1430 to a 1500 on the SAT and a 32 to a 34 on the ACT. Based on those score ranges, Tulane looks selective and prestigious. But, it is widely accepted admissions advice that if a student’s ACT score is below the 25th percentile at a school (so, for Tulane, below a  1430 on the SAT or a 32 on the ACT), then the student should not submit a test score because doing so would hurt their admissions chances. Thus, the real SAT and ACT score range of Tulane (and of other test-optional schools) is much lower, but we simply don’t know how much lower because test-optional colleges don’t capture the SAT and ACT results of all of their students. 

By encouraging students to submit ACT scores of 28, Tulane is signaling two things:

  1. It really wants test scores. Evidently, Tulane would rather students submit lower test scores so it can actually use those test scores in its admissions decisions than not receive any test scores at all. Test-optional is likely in-name-only at Tulane going forward: if you don’t submit a test score, they are going to assume it’s below a 28, and they are going to hold it against you.
  2. By encouraging students with lower scores to submit scores, Tulane’s average SAT and ACT scores are going to drop. Its ranking in US News and World Report might even drop. So Tulane is choosing to gain more information about its applicants’ academic preparedness in order to admit the best students at the expense of the school’s short-term reputation. 

In 2022, writing on behalf of the National Test Prep Association (NTPA), I wrote in a Nasdaq.com op-ed about how people should consider the long-term value of their college degrees, and how test-required colleges, which value academic excellence, are the surest bets in the long term. That said, it still surprises me to see colleges make the tough decision to go through short-term pain for long-term gain. Most people, and especially most institutions, are unwilling to do so.

Dropping Its Supplemental Essay

In 2023, writing on behalf of the NTPA, I wrote in an op-ed for The Hill that college application essays needed to be proctored or discarded – in the age of AI, not doing so simply invited inauthentic essays.

But, again, change is typically slow to arrive, if it ever does. To see Tulane say the quiet part out loud is, frankly, refreshing. Everyone knows that college admissions officers cannot know if a polished essay was written by the student, AI (particularly an advanced model), or a professional editor. But they can probably tell when one was written entirely by AI (or, I would suspect, entirely written by a free AI model). In fact, research shows that it is economically disadvantaged students who are most harmed by using AI for college application essays because they do not use AI as strategically, resulting in formulaic essays.

I do, however, hope that both the SAT and ACT revive their optional essays and change them to ask students a prompt similar to a Common App essay prompt. This will give students the opportunity to turn in a proctored application essay. If possible, we shouldn’t lose this aspect of the college application process: a student’s story is often pivotal to understanding them as an applicant. But, without a proctored essay, colleges are receiving many essays that do not reflect the actual applicant, and, ironically, many colleges are using AI to read and grade those essays, so we have AI evaluating AI. That is clearly ridiculous, so it’s great to see Tulane make this change. Williams College, UVA, Texas Christian University, and Brandeis have already removed their supplemental essays. The University of Georgia has done likewise for the 2026-27 admissions cycle.

Send Your AP Exam Scores

AP exam scores are ascendent. John Latting, the Dean of Admissions at Emory, was the first to say it so definitively: “We’re not as trusting, frankly, of GPA these days… [G]rades are definitely inflated and not as connected to true class performance as they used to be.” The article he is quoted in went on to explain that Emory will be “weighing ‘external assessment’ more heavily than GPA, with a particular focus on AP scores.” Keep in mind, Emory is officially test-optional, yet test scores – particularly AP exam scores – are more important for admission there than a student’s high school grades.

In the last few years, more and more selective colleges have clearly stated that they value AP exam scores in their admissions process. Tulane’s guidance is yet another indication of the increasing importance of AP exam scores: in an age not only of AI but also of rampant grade inflation, colleges are looking for accurate measures of academic preparedness, and an AP exam score is much more trustworthy than a grade in an AP class when most students in AP classes have A’s but most don’t have a 5 on the AP exam.

The Culmination of Converging Forces

Not since Covid, when almost every college went test-optional, has college admissions felt on the cusp of significant change.

Colleges are dealing with unprecedented challenges: 

  • Record grade inflation – in 2024, 84% of students going to a 4-year university had an A-average in high school.
  • The lowest ever recorded Reading and Math proficiency of 12th graders (based on the longitudinal results of the Nation’s Report Card, or NAEP scores).
  • Test-optional admissions that removed the only universally available standardized measure of academic preparedness from admissions consideration (AP exam scores, while standardized, are not universally available).
  • Artificial intelligence that has made unproctored essays largely useless.

In just the last few months, there have been many canaries for college admissions, all calling the same warning song.

  • In November of last year, the University of California, San Diego released a report that 12% of its first-year students (up from less than 1% in 2020) were being placed in remedial math. Of these, over two-thirds were not proficient in even middle school math. And yet, a quarter of those students who were not proficient in middle school math had perfect, straight A’s in high school math. In short, the students’ math grades were worse than useless – they were actually misleading everyone (which is unfair to students and their parents, who could have and should have been informed by the students’ grades that the students were struggling in math, so they could have taken corrective action).
  • Since that letter, many University of California faculty have been in open revolt against the UC’s ban on the use of SAT and ACT scores in its admissions. As of 6/2/2026, over 1,250 UC professors had signed onto a public letter to the UC admissions, calling for the UC system to again require SAT and ACT scores. UC Berkeley also released its own report on the decline in the proficiency of its incoming students; in just two years, between 2021 and 2023, the rate of incoming students who failed Calculus 1 nearly doubled, from 18.5% to 30.7%.
  • In April, Yale released a report that, among many other great recommendations, said colleges needed to return to prioritizing academic achievement. One would think that would not need to be stated. The Yale report pointed out that higher education’s mission misalignment (not prioritizing education) is one reason Americans have lost faith in higher education. While the report didn’t call for other colleges to return to test-required admissions (as Yale itself has), it seemed to imply that other colleges should do so. As Yale has previously stated, “[SAT and ACT] scores are the single greatest predictor of a student’s performance in Yale courses in every model we have constructed.” While SAT and ACT scores are far from perfect, they help a college better understand the academic preparedness of its applicants, so it is contrary to the mission of an academic institution to willfully close its eyes to useful measures of academic preparedness.
  • In mid-May, Princeton voted to discontinue its 144-year-old honor code. It was obvious to faculty at Princeton that its students were cheating, despite the honor code. I would extend this awareness beyond Princeton: the Common App itself and its self-reported activities section relies on an honor code that applicants will tell the truth. This presumption of truthfulness should, unfortunately, no longer be afforded to applicants. It is noble to believe the best about humanity, but it is unwise to let people who lie shine brighter than those who tell the truth.
  • Also in late May, research showed that AI is fueling grade inflation – it’s not just that teachers are grading more leniently, but students are probably turning in higher quality work because AI is doing it for them.
  • In late May, Harvard faculty overwhelmingly voted to cap the percentage of students who could receive A’s because grade inflation at the school was so rampant (as it is at virtually every other college). If grade inflation is not reined in, alternative measures of academic preparedness will emerge. Grade inflation at the high school level has caused the ascendence of AP exam scores: it’s not about “Advanced Placement” anymore; it’s about “Authenticated Proficiency.” The College Board should change what the acronym stands for and expand its AP exams to all core classes so that students, parents, high schools, and colleges get more accurate information about the academic preparedness of students.
  • Media and education outlets are publishing an increasing number of pieces about grade inflation. Most recently, the New York Times did so very bluntly: “It’s Becoming Impossible to Know How Your Kid Is Doing in School.”

What Comes Next

Although change is slow, it now feels unavoidable. I expect the following:

  • Grade inflation is far too apparent to ignore, and students are showing up on college campuses without even middle-school math skills. More colleges will move back to requiring test scores or, as Tulane did, functionally requiring them. If the University of California system goes back to requiring test scores (which looks increasingly likely), it will likely cause a domino effect, at least among top public universities.
  • Colleges will drop the facade that they trust that essays are accurate reflections of an applicant’s own writing and will lessen the importance of essays in their application process (Duke led the charge in this respect when it stopped assigning scores to application essays two years ago). More colleges will drop their supplemental essays altogether.
  • AP exam scores will become ever more important.

You have to give credit to Tulane: they tackled all three. Though the school had been gaming the admissions system, now it is at the forefront of best practices, at least with respect to these three aspects of admissions.

While students might lament a greater emphasis on standardized test scores, we can more accurately view this as a return to a greater emphasis on test scores. Just 6 years ago, almost all colleges required test scores. While grades remain inflated, AP exam scores will step in to function as the grades in AP classes. Thus, while students might view an emphasis on test scores as draconian, it is, in fact, a restoration of colleges seeking accurate measures of academic preparedness that they previously had through less inflated grades and required SAT and ACT scores. Of course, not all grades are inflated, and having good grades from a good high school will still be the most important admissions criterion for the vast majority of colleges.

If you’re looking for greater clarity around testing and college admissions, reach out to us anytime. We love helping students and parents navigate the testing process.

Updates since publishing: The University of Miami dropped its supplemental essay requirement, Columbia University (the only Ivy League institution that had remained test-optional) returned to requiring test scores, the UC Humanities and Social Science professors have started their own letter calling for a return to test-required admissions, and Mercer University also returned to test-required admissions. In July, the Wall Street Journal ran a story about colleges dropping their essays.

SAT® and ACT® are registered trademarks belonging, respectively, to Collegeboard and ACT, Inc. Neither Collegeboard nor ACT, Inc. is involved with or affiliated with Summit Prep®, nor does the SAT or ACT, Inc. endorse or sponsor any of the products or services offered by Summit Prep®.