Selective and highly selective colleges have more highly qualified applicants than they can admit. Once the pool of applicants has been whittled down based on grades, rigor, and/or test scores to those who can succeed academically at a college, then the admissions officers move on to subjective admissions criteria (general fit, specific fit, and institutional priorities). For most rising seniors, much of that criteria (teacher recommendations, extracurricular activities, etc) is already in the past and/or beyond their control. But not the college application essays. Rising seniors can still demonstrate their general and specific fit through their college essays, and, in so doing, greatly increase their chances of admission.
I have already written about general fit (here’s a link), so this post will focus on specific fit, which means that you belong at that college. Doing so takes research and execution on the “why us” supplemental college application essays.
Specific Fit
MIT does a great job of demonstrating just how pivotally important specific fit is on the supplemental college application essays:
“We want students in our community to work towards solutions and make the world a better place. As it relates to our admissions selection process, mission alignment is a critical component. There can be students who are very well qualified, but who ultimately we’re just not going to be that interested in. For example, we have an excellent school of business, Sloan School of Management. Oftentimes, students who are interested in a business education want to develop a product or service that’s going to generate personal wealth. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that, but I have no interest in those students whatsoever [emphasis added].”
-David duKor-Jackson, Director of Admissions at MIT, 2025
“No interest in those students whatsoever.” DuKor-Jackson could not have been clearer: unless you are aiming to solve humanity’s problems, you’re not getting in — even if you are a stellar applicant in every other way.
The more selective the college, the more they can mostly pick whomever they want, so they pick those students who are not just stellar academic students, not just the students who have great qualities in general, but those students who sound like a great fit for MIT.
To demonstrate specific fit, you need to thoroughly research the school, understand its mission and goals, know what they offer, and connect your story, mission, and goals to those of the college. To do that, it helps to go visit, but you should also thoroughly use the college’s “About Us” page. Many top colleges have a blog section. Read that. In it, there are often blog posts from seniors about their college journeys at that school. Those graduating senior blog posts are gold mines, especially if you can find one from a student who majored in your desired major. They’ll often list the clubs and classes that were most helpful: now you have a pre-built path that you can follow and that you can write about in the “why us” supplemental essays.
For instance, let’s say you want to attend Dartmouth but be on a pre-med track. The deck is stacked against you because Dartmouth doesn’t have a pre-med track. However, if you were to stumble upon Olivia Koo’s blog posts, you’d learn that the “Nathan Smith Society is the main club for pre-health students,” Dartmouth has a “Pre-Health Advising Center,” pre-med students get “weekly newsletters and opportunities, especially tied to the Geisel School of Medicine and Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center.” In short, from Koo’s post, you get a pre-med playbook for the “why Dartmouth” essay.
Chatgpt can also give good information, but it’s better as a search tool (I have found it to be better than Google) for finding student blog posts, mission statements, etc. Use the links from Chatgpt to read the actual blog posts and mission statements from colleges. It’s not sufficient to just read the summaries of those blog posts and mission statements on Chatgpt because Chatgpt removes much of the nuance, and you need the nuance to write compelling supplemental “Why Us” essays.
In short, do your research and connect your own past activities, interests, and goals to the mission of the school you’re applying to.
Timeline
Below is the ideal timeline for college essays:
- June to July: Work on the Common App personal statement. These prompts very rarely change from year to year.
- August to October: Work on the supplemental college application essays. These essay prompts for individual colleges become available through the Common App on August 1st of each year. Ideally, students will finish these essays before school starts, but, typically, students are working on them until at least the end of September. If a student is applying to 20 top schools (which I’m not recommending but which is becoming more common as the admit rates to those schools decline), they could be writing 40 supplemental essays. But, luckily, after a student has written about 10 of these, they rarely have to start from scratch and can instead repurpose the supplemental essays they have already written.
- October to November: Make sure everything in the Common App is pristine. Even the wording of the descriptions of a student’s extracurricular activities can matter, so make sure that these are concise and, if possible, impactful.
- November 1st: Click submit. This is the early application deadline (Early Action and Early Decision) for most colleges. (Our guide to whether a student should apply Early Decision has the odds, the rules and the data.)
- If a student still needs to get their scores up, keep taking the SAT and/or ACT.
- December: Find out early application decisions.
- January: If needed, apply Regular Decision (which is becoming Irregular Decision, given that so many students apply early) and potentially apply Early Decision Round 2 to a college.
- May 1st: The deposit deadline at most colleges. However, more and more schools are offering students who didn’t enroll even more merit aid both before and even after this deadline. These are typically less selective colleges that missed their class enrollment numbers, so students would typically be trading a more prestigious school name for more money from a less prestigious school if they switch, but, on the margins, we have seen more students than ever before rescind their enrollments and switch to another college — even after May 1st. (See here for information on how colleges use financial incentives to compete for applicants.)
Recap
College application essays are both my most and least favorite part of the college application. More than anywhere else, the essay turns an applicant of numbers and activities into a person of character and depth. But, there are no instruction manuals from colleges: if someone had told Zach Yadegari that even a drop of arrogance would poison his whole application, then he probably would have shown humility, not arrogance, and he might very well have been accepted — not outright rejected — by most top colleges. There are also no fences guarding against dishonesty in essays. Virtually no students have been caught lying on their college application essays (and the most high-profile person caught is probably innocent).
With no instruction manuals or fences, college application essays are a tough space in which to compete, which is why so many students hire coaches for application essays. But, if you do it alone, make sure to do your research: demonstrate general fit in your Common App essay, demonstrate your understanding of a college and your fit for that college in the supplemental essays, show your integrity and gratitude throughout, and get someone (probably Chatgpt then) to read over your essays to make sure that they are grammatically correct, structured well, flow smoothly, and aligned with what colleges are looking for.
