To choose between the SAT and the ACT, take an official practice test of each, compare the two scores using the official concordance table, pick the test that fits you better, and prepare for that one test. For most students whose scores come out close, we give the ACT a slight edge, for reasons we explain below. But if your SAT score is clearly ahead, take the SAT.
Although imperfect, the SAT and ACT are phenomenal tests. Each one has real strengths, and the two are different enough that many students score noticeably better on one than the other. So the decision deserves a full practice test of each before a single hour of preparation.
- Take an official practice test of each, timed, in one sitting, in the format you would actually test in.
- Compare the two total scores with the official concordance table (it’s below).
- If the scores are close, use the tie-breakers: where you can improve, how you handle pace, which format and calculator you’d test with, your grade, and what your colleges ask for.
- Prepare for one test, not both.
How to Choose Between the SAT and ACT
First, all students should take an official mock test of each. For the SAT, that means a full-length practice test in the College Board’s Bluebook app, which is timed, scored and adaptive like the real test. For the ACT, it means one of ACT’s free full-length practice tests, taken under the real timing in the format you plan to use (paper or online). Take each one in a single sitting, with the breaks the real test gives and nothing else. A student who takes the Math section on Tuesday and the Reading section on Thursday has learned something about their content knowledge and nothing about their stamina, and stamina counts on test day.
Don’t use a test developed by a prep company as your diagnostic. In our experience, these tests are often inaccurate, and some give students lower scores, which makes the student appear to improve more on the real test. The official tests are the real thing, or as close as a practice test gets, and they’re free.
If you already have a real score, use it. A school-day SAT or ACT counts as a diagnostic of that test, and a good one, because nothing predicts a real test like a real test. You still need an official practice test of the other exam before you decide. (If you will test with extended time or another accommodation, practice with the same accommodation on both tests; a practice setting isn’t an approval, and each testing agency approves accommodations separately.)
Then compare the two totals. An SAT score and an ACT score are on different scales (400 to 1600 and 1 to 36), so you need the official conversion, which is the next section. For most students, it’s sufficient to pick the test on which the student has the higher equivalent score. If the SAT score is less than 50 points above the ACT score’s SAT equivalent, keep reading, because the tie-breakers below decide it.
Most families will invest considerable time and resources preparing for one test or the other, not both (except in very rare circumstances), so decide your destination wisely before you start the trip. Switching tests midway through preparation is sometimes right (when to switch), but it’s always cheaper to choose well at the start.
| Practice scores | Lean toward | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One test is clearly ahead | That test | A head start beats any feature |
| Close, and pace is the problem | The one you paced better | Pace is slow to fix |
| Close, no pace problem | The tie-breakers below | Your score split first; then we lean ACT |
SAT to ACT Score Conversion: The Official Table
The official way to compare an SAT score with an ACT score is the concordance table that the College Board and ACT published together in 2018. The table below is their ACT-to-SAT table, and it works in both directions: read it left to right to turn an ACT Composite into an SAT total, and use the range column to turn an SAT total into an ACT Composite (any SAT total from 590 to 1600 falls in exactly one range). A 1300 on the SAT, for instance, falls in the 1300 to 1320 range, so it compares with a 28 on the ACT. A 33 on the ACT lists 1460 as its SAT comparison point, and every SAT total from 1450 to 1480 concords back to a 33.
| ACT | SAT | SAT range |
|---|---|---|
| 36 | 1590 | 1570 to 1600 |
| 35 | 1540 | 1530 to 1560 |
| 34 | 1500 | 1490 to 1520 |
| 33 | 1460 | 1450 to 1480 |
| 32 | 1430 | 1420 to 1440 |
| 31 | 1400 | 1390 to 1410 |
| 30 | 1370 | 1360 to 1380 |
| 29 | 1340 | 1330 to 1350 |
| 28 | 1310 | 1300 to 1320 |
| 27 | 1280 | 1260 to 1290 |
| 26 | 1240 | 1230 to 1250 |
| 25 | 1210 | 1200 to 1220 |
| 24 | 1180 | 1160 to 1190 |
| 23 | 1140 | 1130 to 1150 |
| 22 | 1110 | 1100 to 1120 |
| 21 | 1080 | 1060 to 1090 |
| 20 | 1040 | 1030 to 1050 |
| 19 | 1010 | 990 to 1020 |
| 18 | 970 | 960 to 980 |
| 17 | 930 | 920 to 950 |
| 16 | 890 | 880 to 910 |
| 15 | 850 | 830 to 870 |
| 14 | 800 | 780 to 820 |
| 13 | 760 | 730 to 770 |
| 12 | 710 | 690 to 720 |
| 11 | 670 | 650 to 680 |
| 10 | 630 | 620 to 640 |
| 9 | 590 | 590 to 610 |
These are the official 2018 concordance tables. ACT’s 2025 report on the enhanced test supports their continued use, and the College Board’s 2023 study put digital and paper SAT scores on the same scale. Concordance compares results; it cannot predict exactly how a student will perform on the other test. In plain terms: a 31 and a 1400 were earned by students at about the same rank among students who took both tests, which makes them comparable scores, not interchangeable ones. The agencies have not published a new study pairing the enhanced ACT with the digital SAT, so this remains the table colleges and counselors use.
Three things the table is not for. Don’t compare percentiles instead: each test publishes percentiles against its own test takers, and those are different groups of students, so “93rd percentile” on one test does not mean the same thing as “93rd percentile” on the other. Don’t build a superscore across the two tests; colleges superscore within a test, not between them. And don’t use it for National Merit, where a confirming score is a separate calculation with its own rules (see our guide to National Merit confirming scores).
So how far ahead does an SAT score need to be before the SAT is the obvious choice? Our rule of thumb is 50 points. Convert the ACT score to its SAT equivalent in the table, then subtract it from the actual SAT score. A student with a 1450 on the SAT and a 32 on the ACT (which compares with a 1430) is 20 points ahead on the SAT, which is a tie, so the tie-breakers decide. A student with a 1400 and a 29 (a 1340) is 60 points ahead, so that student should take the SAT, because it would take a significant amount of work on the ACT just to catch up to the SAT score before surpassing it. The 50 points are our judgment from years of these comparisons, not an official threshold, and the next sections explain what else we weigh.
SAT vs. ACT: The Differences Today
Both tests measure fundamental knowledge and skills in grammar, reading, mathematics and data analysis. Here is how the current versions of the two tests actually differ, from the agencies’ own pages.
| What | SAT | ACT |
|---|---|---|
| Required sections | Reading and Writing; Math | English; Math; Reading |
| Questions and time | 98 in 134 min | 131 in 125 min |
| Optional sections | None | Science; Writing |
| Score | 400 to 1600 | 1 to 36 Composite |
| Format | Digital (Bluebook) | Paper or online |
| Adaptive? | Yes, by section | No (linear) |
| Calculator | Desmos built in | Desmos online; handheld on paper |
| Your questions back | No | On some dates |
Pace. The ACT gives you less time per question in every section: about 42 seconds per English question, 67 per Math question and 67 per Reading question, against about 71 seconds per Reading and Writing question and 95 per Math question on the SAT (the section times divided by the question counts). The averages overstate the difference a little, because the SAT gives each Reading and Writing question its own short passage while ACT English and Reading questions share a passage, so some ACT questions take seconds and others take a minute. But the direction is right: the ACT is the faster test, and students who run out of time on the ACT practice test have learned something important.
Adaptive. The SAT’s two sections each have two modules. The first module of each section mixes easy, medium and hard questions; how you do on it decides whether your second module is, on average, harder or easier, and the harder module is where the highest scores live. The ACT doesn’t do this: its test is linear, so the questions don’t change with your answers, whether you test on paper or on a screen. Some students like knowing what’s coming. Some find it nerve-racking to feel the second module get harder (which is, actually, good news when it happens).
Scoring. The SAT total is the Reading and Writing score plus the Math score, each from 200 to 800. The ACT Composite is the average of the English, Math and Reading scores, rounded to the nearest whole number, so English and Reading together are two-thirds of the Composite and Math is one-third. Science, when you take it, gets its own score and feeds an ACT STEM score, but since September 2025 it no longer counts in the Composite or in a superscore, and Writing is scored separately on a 2 to 12 scale. (A score from before the change was computed under the old rules; don’t recompute it.)
Calculators. Bluebook has the Desmos graphing calculator built in for the whole Math section, and you may bring an approved handheld too. The online ACT embeds Desmos in its Math section as well, so the calculator is a difference between formats, not between tests, and paper ACT testers rely on a permitted handheld. Neither test allows a calculator with a computer algebra system, and the SAT requires that algebra-solving programs be removed from a handheld, so a student who leans on an advanced calculator should read both calculator policies before test day.
Advantages of the SAT
We like the digital SAT. The last version (the paper test that ran from 2016 to 2023) had some subjective questions and curves on the grammar and Math sections that could be absolutely brutal. The digital test fixed that: the questions have provably correct answers, and the adaptive design gives the test more precision at the top of the scale, where the old test punished one careless mistake. The SAT’s real advantages for a student choosing between the tests are these.
Fewer Math topics, tested more deeply. The SAT’s Math section covers four domains (algebra, advanced math, problem solving and data analysis, and geometry and trigonometry). The ACT’s Math description reaches further, into topics such as complex numbers and logarithmic functions that the SAT’s specification doesn’t list. Instead of breadth, the SAT tests depth: because it covers fewer topics, the questions on those topics are trickier and often require deeper understanding. For a student whose math stopped at Algebra II, that’s a shorter syllabus. (Our guide to ACT Math formulas shows what the wider syllabus looks like.)
More time per question, and short passages. A student who knows the material but reads carefully is rarely rushed on the SAT. And every Reading and Writing question comes with its own short text, so a student never has to hold a long passage in mind across ten questions. Students who find long passages tiring often prefer this.
Desmos. If you’re good at the Desmos calculator, you have a significant advantage on the SAT, because it’s available for every Math question. Our advice from the first digital tests still holds: in practice, solve every question you can with Desmos, then redo the same problems by hand, so that you understand the mathematics well enough to handle a question written to defeat the calculator.
Real, free, adaptive practice. The College Board’s Bluebook app has full-length practice tests that are timed, scored and adaptive like the real thing, paper versions of those tests as PDFs for students approved to test on paper, and a Student Question Bank with thousands of official questions sorted by skill and difficulty. The digital SAT’s practice supply is not what it was in the spring of 2024, when we worried about it. It’s good now.
Vocabulary pays. The SAT tests vocabulary directly, in its words-in-context questions and in the reading level of its passages. A student willing to spend real hours learning words can raise a Reading and Writing score in a way that has no ACT equivalent. In our experience, few students actually spend those hours, which is why we also count this as a disadvantage.
More fall test dates for seniors. The SAT offers more Weekend dates from August through December than the ACT offers National dates, which matters to a senior finishing in the fall.
Advantages of the ACT
Both a pro and a con of the ACT is its flexibility: it offers a paper and an online format, an optional Science section and an optional Writing essay. The flexibility is nice, but it creates confusion about what to do, so here are the broad strokes before the advantages. Writing is unnecessary for most students; a couple of the colleges we track recommend it and none requires it, so check your colleges and skip it otherwise (we list which colleges use ACT Writing scores). Our rule of thumb is to take Science if you score a 30 or above and are applying to highly selective colleges, and to take it at any score if a college or program on your list asks for it (we list which colleges use ACT Science scores). And in our experience the paper format has some distinct advantages over the online format, which we walk through in our post on Desmos and the digital ACT.
It rewards preparation. The ACT asks what you know and whether you can do it quickly: grammar, rhetoric, mathematics, reading and data analysis. There are no shortcuts, and there’s less of a ceiling on the score of a hard-working student. Either students put in the time to learn all the content and skills, or they don’t do well, so the test rewards those who master the fundamentals. The SAT measures real knowledge and skills too, but its trickier questions give some students a larger inherent advantage, and in our experience large gains on the ACT come more reliably from hours of content work. Some people think a test that can be prepared for is a weaker admissions test. We think achievement is the better gauge, because a test that rewards preparation measures what students actually learned.
Real tests, and your own test back. ACT publishes four full-length official practice tests free, each as a PDF and online, and its Official ACT Prep Guide has four full-length tests of its own (ACT doesn’t say whether the book’s tests differ from the free ones, so don’t count on eight). Older official ACT tests still make excellent practice for the content and skills, even though their timing and some question formats differ from today’s test. And here is the advantage the SAT can’t match: on the National test dates that offer My Answer Key, a student who orders it gets back the questions from their own test, their answers and the answer key, so they can see exactly what they missed on a real test and practice it. (Our ACT My Answer Key converter turns that report into a scored, reviewable test.) The College Board offers no Question-and-Answer Service for the digital SAT, so an SAT student can’t order their own test back.
You can cancel a bad date. Unless you tested through a state or district program (ACT’s terms also exclude on-campus testing), you can ask ACT to permanently cancel the scores from a test date by contacting ACT through its online contact route and returning the form it sends; ACT notifies any college that already received that date’s scores. The SAT offers a short window instead: a cancellation requested in My SAT by 11:59 p.m. Eastern one week after an SAT Weekend test, which can’t be undone, and after that the College Board’s pages describe no way to remove one date from your record (you choose which dates to send, but a sent date shows both sections). In our experience, knowing that a bad day can be cancelled is psychologically helpful for students, even if they never use the option. Which scores colleges actually see, and how sending works on each test, is the subject of our guide to whether colleges see all of your scores.
Dates that fit a junior’s year. The ACT offers February and July National dates, which the SAT doesn’t, so a junior can keep testing through the spring and over the summer and is less likely to be stuck finishing in the fall of senior year. For the 2026-27 testing year, the ACT offers February and July National dates, while the SAT offers more August-through-December Weekend dates; choose around the student’s grade and actual college deadlines. (Calendars checked November 3, 2026; the current agency calendars are in our SAT and ACT testing timeline, and the last dates each college accepts are in our post on the last SAT and ACT test dates colleges accept.)
Paper or online, your choice. Some students think better on paper; some want the on-screen Desmos calculator for Math. The ACT lets you pick the format when you register (the SAT is digital for everyone without a paper accommodation). One qualifier: the format is fixed for that registration. ACT allows a change only before its change deadline, for a fee and if a seat is open, and never at the test center on the day. So taking the paper test and then the online test for its Desmos means two test dates, not one, and whether the second date is worth it depends on the student’s grades and time.
Extended time. In our experience, virtually all students who test with extended time score comparatively higher on the ACT than on the SAT, because extra time removes much of the time pressure that is part of the ACT. The reasoning is in our post on extended time on the SAT and ACT; confirm it with a practice test of each under your approved conditions.
Which Test Is Easier to Improve On?
When the two practice scores are close, the question is no longer which test you scored higher on. It’s which test you can improve more on. Here is how we think about it.
Strong verbal, weak Math: lean SAT. Weak verbal, strong Math: lean ACT. This is the opposite of what most families expect, and it’s our observation from years of tutoring, not an agency statistic. The SAT’s Reading and Writing section is harder to improve than SAT Math. On the ACT, it’s reversed: English and Reading are, for most students, easier to improve than ACT Math, and they’re two-thirds of the Composite. So a student with a high verbal score and a low Math score is usually a better candidate for the SAT (the Math can be raised), and a student with a low verbal score and a high Math score is usually a better candidate for the ACT (the English and Reading can be raised). One override: if the verbal weakness is reading speed in English, as it often is for students educated abroad, the SAT’s slower pace and short passages may fit better than the ACT’s, and the diagnostic will show it.
Pace. If you finished the SAT comfortably and ran out of time on the ACT, believe that evidence. Pace improves with practice, but a student who needs every minute of the SAT’s 95 seconds per Math question is starting the ACT from behind.
Format and calculator. A student who thinks on paper has one real option (the paper ACT). A student who lives in Desmos has two (the SAT and the online ACT).
Grade. A sophomore or junior with time has the ACT’s February and July dates on their side. A senior finishing in the fall has more SAT dates.
So, in sum, we give the ACT a slight edge. It rewards learning, it has real past tests to practice from and gives students their own test back, it lets students cancel a bad date, its verbal sections are two-thirds of the score and (in our experience) the easier two-thirds to raise, and its calendar suits a junior. Granted, the ACT’s margin is thinner than it was before the digital SAT and the enhanced ACT: the digital SAT’s practice supply is good now, the online ACT gave up the calculator difference, and a senior gets more SAT dates. But if a student is scoring an equivalent 50 points higher or more on the SAT, then they still should do the SAT, because they are starting far enough ahead that it would take a significant amount of work on the ACT just to catch up to that score before surpassing it.
Do Colleges Prefer the SAT or the ACT?
Not as a rule. Nearly every college that uses test scores accepts either test, and the colleges that address the question say they have no preference. Yale’s testing page says, “The admissions office does not prefer scores from one exam over the other.” Dartmouth’s says, “Dartmouth has no institutional preference for either test.” Stanford’s says, “Stanford does not have a preferred exam (ACT vs. SAT).” Penn’s admissions FAQ says the same, and our post on submitting both an SAT and an ACT score quotes all four. ACT’s own comparison page says both tests are accepted at all accredited US colleges, which is nearly true: the University of Puerto Rico at Río Piedras, for one, says on its admission requirements page that it does not accept the ACT. And a test-blind college uses neither test, which is a different thing from preferring one. So check the colleges on your list, but don’t choose a test to please them.
Superscoring is close to a wash. In the Forbes top 500, 216 colleges state that they superscore the SAT and 201 state that they superscore the ACT, and many more let applicants self-report their best section scores, which in our reading works much like a superscore; our sortable tables of which colleges superscore the SAT and which colleges superscore the ACT have every college’s policy. Merit scholarships are where the two tests are most often treated differently, so if an automatic scholarship is in play, check our post on which colleges superscore for merit scholarships.
Check Your Colleges Before You Register
The test is your choice; the rules around it are each college’s. Before you register, check your list against our maintained tables:
- Whether scores are required at all: which colleges require the SAT or ACT.
- Superscoring: SAT and ACT.
- The optional sections: ACT Science and ACT Writing.
- Scholarships that still want a score at test-optional colleges: test-optional scholarship requirements.
- The last test date each college accepts for Early Decision, Early Action and Regular Decision: last SAT and ACT test dates by college.
For when to start preparing, how many times to test and how to finish on time, use our SAT and ACT testing timeline. And once you have a score, our post on whether to submit your SAT or ACT scores covers the next decision.
A Short History, and Why the Tests Still Feel Different
Past is prologue, so a bit of history explains the difference in feel. The first SAT was given in 1926, designed as an aptitude test that would help top colleges find students with great potential who did not attend one of the elite private schools. The ACT arrived in the fall of 1959 as an achievement test, built to measure what students had learned in school. Both tests say today that they measure the knowledge and skills taught in school, and both do. As we read the history, the 2016 redesign made the two tests more alike than they had ever been, and the digital SAT (international students in March 2023, US students in March 2024) turned the trickiness back up, with more inference-heavy questions, while the enhanced ACT (National online testing from April 2025, paper from September 2025) kept the ACT’s straightforward, know-it-and-do-it-fast character. That difference in character is why the same student can score a 31 on one and a 1300 on the other, and it’s why the diagnostic comes first.
What Changed in the SAT and ACT
- The SAT went digital and adaptive for US students in March 2024 (international students in March 2023). Starting in spring 2027, the College Board will report a Science Practices and Foundations score from existing SAT questions, with no new section and no extra testing time, and it says that score will not be sent to colleges and universities.
- The enhanced ACT began with National online testing in April 2025 and National paper testing in September 2025: a shorter core test, four answer choices in Math, and Science and Writing both optional.
Caption: Checked on the College Board’s and ACT’s pages, November 3, 2026.
Three smaller notes. Outside the US, the ACT is given in short testing windows rather than on single National dates, and the SAT follows its worldwide Weekend calendar; our page on online SAT and ACT tutoring for international students covers seats, formats and time zones. A PSAT score tells you roughly where an SAT practice test will land (PSAT to SAT conversion), but it doesn’t replace the full SAT diagnostic, and it says nothing about the ACT. And a few colleges also accept the CLT; our post on whether your child should take the CLT is the three-way comparison.
The Bottom Line
Take an official mock test of each, compare your scores, pick the one that fits you best given your circumstances, and prepare. If you work hard, you can and will succeed. When you’re ready to prepare, our SAT tutoring and ACT tutoring pages explain how we work, and our practice tests page is where to get the diagnostics proctored. Questions about which test fits your student? We love answering questions. Reach out to us anytime.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the ACT easier than the SAT?
Neither test is easier; they’re different. The ACT is faster (less time per question in every section) and covers more Math topics; the SAT is slower, covers fewer topics in more depth, and asks trickier questions. The same student can find one of them much easier, which is why we start with a practice test of each rather than with anyone’s opinion, including ours.
Which test is more popular, the SAT or the ACT?
The SAT, in recent graduating classes. In the class of 2026, the College Board counted 1,954,833 students who took the SAT during high school, and ACT counted 1,463,293 graduates with a reportable ACT score (each agency’s annual report, checked November 3, 2026), a gap of about half a million. Some students are in both counts, and popularity says nothing about which test is better for a particular student.
Can I take both the SAT and the ACT?
Yes, and most students should take a practice test of each, which is the whole point of this post. Preparing for both real tests is a different matter: it splits your study time, and one strong score on one test is all a college needs. The narrow exception is a student with a top score on one test who could match it on the other with little extra work; our post on submitting both scores explains when that helps.
What is a 1400 on the SAT equal to on the ACT?
A 31. In the official concordance, SAT totals from 1390 to 1410 compare with an ACT Composite of 31, and a 31 lists 1400 as its SAT comparison point. A 1450 compares with a 33 and a 1550 with a 35. The full table is above.
Should I switch from the SAT to the ACT if my score stopped improving?
Sometimes. If a student has prepared for months without an increase, a practice test of the other exam costs one Saturday and can reveal a better fit. Our post on switching between the SAT and ACT covers when the switch pays and when it’s just a change of scenery.
Sources: the College Board’s and ACT’s pages linked above, all checked November 3, 2026, and the 2018 ACT/SAT concordance tables.
